P. 102.-78.-302. Lucio. - and he is a motion generative that's infallible. I think we should read ungenerative, which I conceive is confirmed by Lucio's afterwards calling the Duke this ungenitur'd agent. P. 103.-78.-303. Duke. I never heard the absent duke much detected for women. Detected of felony, though not the usual mode of construction at present, means, I believe, the same as detected in felony. P. 108.-83.-311. Duke. He who the sword of heaven will bear, Should be as holy as severe; Pattern in himself to know Grace to stand, and virtue go. I believe Malone has explained this rightly. P. 109.-83.-312. Twice treble shame on Angelo, To weed my vice, and let his grow! Malone is clearly right. Ibid. How may likeness, made in crimes, Most pond'rous and substantial things! I very much doubt whether mocking be the right word. P. 117.-88.-321. Duke. Our corn's to reap, for yet our tithe's to sow. I incline to prefer tilth to tithe. P. 124.-93.-330. Enter a Messenger. Duke. This is his lordship's man, This speech is rightly given to the Provost for the reason assigned by Dr. Johnson. P. 126.-95.–332. Prov. A man insensible of mortality, and desperately mortal. I rather incline to think that Dr. Johnson's last explanation is the true one. P. 129.-97.-335. Clo. First, here's young master Rash. I do not think there is any allusion in this name to the stuff called rash, but to the common signification of the word, hasty, violent, precipi tate. P. 131.-98.-339. All great doers in our trade, and are now for the Lord's sake. I prefer Dr. Warburton's explanation to Dr. Johnson's. P. 133.-100.-341. Duke. Unfit to live, or die: O, gravel heart! After him, fellows; bring him to the block. I agree with Tyrwhitt. It is clear that the Provost did not wish that Barnardine should be immediately executed, as the accident of Ragozine's death had removed the occasion for it. The sun hath made his journal greeting to I would read yonder generations, as in former editions. Some editors seem extremely fond of mangling the verse. Duke. P. 134.-102.-344. from thence By cold gradation and weal-balanced form, I heartily concur in the opinion of Heath and Hanmer. P. 139.-105.-349. Ang. How might she tongue me? Yet reason dares I incline to think that this is rightly explained by Mr. Malone. I agree to Dr. Johnson's explanation; but I am not quite sure that Theobald is not right. I have since read Mr. M. Mason's note: I prefer his reading (vailful) to Theobald's. P. 146.-110.-358. Duke. Her madness hath the oddest frame of sense, Such a dependency of thing on thing, As e'er I heard in madness. Surely we should read ne'er. but let your reason serve, To make the truth appear, where it seems hid; And hide the false seems true. This I do not understand. P. 148.-112.-361. Isab. O, that it were as like, as it is true! Like here clearly means probable. (In some of 1 the western counties a likely man is commonly used for a well-looking man.) P. 149.-113.-362..... and, with ripen'd time, Unfold the evil which is here wrapt up In countenance. I prefer Mr. M. Mason's explanation, which is not very dissimilar to Mr. Malone's. P. 150.-114.-363. F. Peter. I know him for a man divine and holy, Before I had read Malone's note, I had supposed that a temporary meddler might mean, one who meddles with the occurrences of the times, as they present themselves. I am rather surprised to find Mr. Malone's note omitted in the edition of 1793. Р. 151.-114.-364. To justify this worthy nobleman, Vulgarly, I believe in this place means grossly. Ibid.-365. Duke. - Come, cousin Angelo; If partial and impartial may have the same meaning (which the passages produced seem to prove) impartial may stand; if not, Theobald is incontrovertibly right. Lucio. P. 160.-122.-375. show your sheep-biting face, and be hang'd an hour ! Mr. Henley is certainly wrong. An hour is the time that criminals when executed usually remain hanging. P. 163.-125.-379. Duke. Although by confiscation they are ours. I concur with Mr. Steevens. Isab. P. 164.-126.-381. I partly think, A due sincerity govern'd his deed, I doubt whether the poet meant all that Dr. Johnson supposes. Since writing the above, I have read Mr. Ritson's note, with whom I agree. P. 166.-128.-383. Duke. By this, lord Angelo perceives he's safe; It is passing strange; but Shakespeare shews here, as he does in other places, that he was in a hurry to get to the end of his work. P. 168.-129.-386. Duke. Thanks, good friend Escalus, for thy much goodness: There's more behind, that is more gratulate. Malone appears to me to be right: his note should, I think, have been inserted in the edition of 1793. Dr. Johnson's judgment of the serious part of this play appears rather a harsh one. Mr. Harris (the Author of Hermes) once spoke of it to me as a great favourite of his. |